If you are looking for integrative mental health care in California, click here.

Sign up for the Sleep Study newsletter for outpatient physicians and therapists.

Sign Me Up
Online Store Free Sleep Course for Doctors

When to order a sleep study, and how to read a negative one

Sleep affects almost every system in the body, which is why I have a pretty low threshold for asking my patients about it.

On the mental health side, poor sleep can show up as depression that isn’t responding to treatment, anxiety, mood instability, problems with attention and concentration, and cognitive changes. On the physical side, untreated sleep disorders are associated with metabolic dysfunction, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, hypertension and atrial fibrillation.

The problem is that patients don’t always come in complaining about their sleep.

A lot of people have lived with poor sleep for so long that being tired just feels normal. Others don’t realize their sleep is disrupted at all.

That’s why sleep needs to be on our radar even when it isn’t the patient’s chief complaint.

When should you consider ordering a sleep study?

Some patients are obvious.

They snore loudly. Their partner has seen them stop breathing. They’re waking up gasping, with a dry mouth or a headache. They’re falling asleep during the day.

Those patients are probably already making you think about obstructive sleep apnea and a sleep study.

But sleep apnea doesn’t always look like that.

I see it in thin patients. I see it in women who don’t have the stereotypical presentation at all. Sometimes the complaint isn’t snoring or sleepiness. It’s insomnia, fatigue, brain fog, anxiety or depression.

So if something isn’t adding up clinically, think about sleep.

I also consider sleep testing when a patient has insomnia that isn’t improving despite appropriate treatment. If they’ve done CBT-I, tried medications or supplements, worked on their sleep habits, and they’re still struggling, I start wondering whether something else is disrupting their sleep.

The same goes for someone who says, “I sleep eight hours, but I’m exhausted all the time.”

That’s not something I’d automatically chalk up to stress.

A sleep study can tell you more than whether someone has sleep apnea

We tend to use “sleep study” and “sleep apnea test” interchangeably, but they’re not the same thing.

There are over 40 recognized sleep disorders, and obstructive sleep apnea is only one disorder on the differential.

Depending on the type of study, sleep testing can help us evaluate for things like periodic limb movement disorder, REM sleep behavior disorder and narcolepsy. We can also use sleep studies to see whether a treatment is effective.

For example, if someone is using positive airway pressure or an oral appliance for sleep apnea, testing can help determine whether the treatment is adequately controlling their breathing events.

One distinction that’s worth knowing: restless leg syndrome doesn’t require a sleep study. The symptoms happen while the patient is awake, so it’s a clinical diagnosis. Periodic limb movement disorder is different and does require sleep testing.

Not every sleep study happens in a lab

When I recommend a sleep study, patients often immediately picture spending the night in a laboratory covered in wires.

Sometimes that’s exactly what we need. But there are several different types of sleep testing.

There’s in-lab polysomnography, which gives us the most comprehensive look at sleep. There are home sleep apnea tests, which are much easier for many patients and can be a good place to start when obstructive sleep apnea is suspected.

There are also split-night studies, titration studies and multiple sleep latency tests for conditions like narcolepsy. Some sleep centers even offer daytime testing for shift workers or people whose circadian rhythms don’t line up with a traditional nighttime schedule.

The right test depends on what you’re actually looking for.

What if the sleep study is negative?

This is where I see people get tripped up.

A patient has a sleep study. It comes back negative. Everyone checks sleep apnea off the list and moves on.

But sleep isn’t exactly the same every night.

A single night of testing is one snapshot. If your clinical suspicion is still high, a negative result doesn’t necessarily mean you’re done evaluating the patient.

Sometimes I’ll repeat testing. Some clinics offer multi-night home testing. And if a home sleep apnea test is negative but I still strongly suspect sleep apnea, I’ll consider an in-lab polysomnogram.

Insurance unfortunately plays a big role in what testing we can order and in what sequence. Sometimes you have to start with the home study before the insurer will approve an in-lab study.

Should you order the sleep study yourself or refer to a sleep specialist?

This depends on your training, your comfort level and what resources you have available.

I’m board certified in sleep medicine, but my clinical practice is a psychiatry practice and we don’t perform sleep studies.

I could order the study myself and coordinate with a sleep center. Most of the time, I prefer referring the patient for a sleep medicine consultation.

That way the sleep physician can decide which test is appropriate, interpret the results in the context of the patient’s symptoms, and get them set up with treatment if something is found.

I still review the sleep study myself and collaborate with the sleep physician, but the patient gets end-to-end sleep care through the sleep clinic.

Two things I hear from patients all the time

“I won’t be able to sleep in the lab.”

That’s okay. Depending on what we’re looking for, we may be able to start with a home sleep test. Multi-night testing can also be helpful in some situations.

The other one is:

“I already had a sleep study. It was normal.”

Then I ask when they had it.

“Seven years ago.”

Sleep changes with time.

That’s like telling me your A1c was normal seven years ago. It’s useful information, but it doesn’t necessarily tell us what’s happening today.

A few clinical pearls

  • Have a low threshold for thinking about sleep. Your patient doesn’t need to complain about sleep for a sleep disorder to be affecting their health.
  • Don’t rely on the stereotypical picture of obstructive sleep apnea. Women and thin patients can have sleep apnea too, and their symptoms may be much less obvious.
  • If insomnia isn’t responding the way you’d expect, consider whether another sleep disorder is disrupting sleep.
  • A negative sleep study doesn’t always end the evaluation. If your pre-test probability remains high, consider whether repeat or different testing is appropriate.
  • Restless leg syndrome is a clinical diagnosis. Periodic limb movement disorder requires sleep testing.
  • And don’t assume a sleep study from several years ago answers the question you’re asking today.

Sleep is one of those areas where asking a few additional questions can completely change the clinical picture.

I’ve had patients come in thinking their fatigue, brain fog or treatment-resistant symptoms were simply something they had to live with, only to find out there was an untreated sleep disorder in the background.

That’s why I think sleep deserves a place in our differential much more often than it gets one.

If you’d like to learn more about evaluating sleep in clinical practice, our free clinical sleep mini-course for practitioners covers sleep testing, differential diagnosis and referral in more detail.

Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and isn’t intended to replace individualized medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.

Have a patient who needs more than education? My clinical practice, Pacific Integrative Psychiatry, accepts referrals for insomnia and mental health care in California.

Referring a patient for the sleep program? Effortless Sleep™ for clinicians has the referral details.

Not a clinician? The Effortless Sleep Program™ is the patient version of this work, available online, nationwide.

Get these videos delivered straight to your inbox

Sign up for my newsletter & get immediate access to sleep & wellness tips.

Sign Me Up